The more recent allegation against Gaiman comes from a 23-year-old woman named Scarlett who says that she met the author in 2022 when she came to his home to work as a nanny to his child.

During that time, Scarlett and Neil Gaiman developed what both of them agree was a consensual relationship. However, according to Scarlett, during the course of this short-lived relationship, the author subjected her to degrading sexual acts which she was not okay with.

The second allegation against Neil Gaiman stems from much earlier, dating back to 2003 when a woman identified only as K says she met the author at a book signing event when she was 18.

According to K, when she turned 20, she entered into a relationship with Gaiman that became sexual. She alleges that he wound up sexually interacting with her in ways that were painful and unwanted.